Q: A method is long if its LoC exceeds 20. True or False?
๐ Analysis of Method Length Criteria
The statement suggests that a method is considered โlongโ if its Lines of Code (LoC) exceed 20. At first glance, this appears to be a specific and measurable claim. However, in the field of software engineering, such a classification requires deeper context.
๐ Evaluation
This statement is an oversimplification of a nuanced software development principle. The perception of whether a method is “long” depends on several important factors:
- ๐งฉ Programming Language: Some languages are more verbose than others, affecting LoC naturally.
- ๐ข Team or Organization Standards: Development teams often have internal style guides and code length rules.
- ๐ฏ Purpose & Complexity of the Method: A method performing multiple operations may require more lines by necessity.
- ๐ Code Readability: Maintaining readability sometimes requires breaking a method into more lines for clarity.
Although many software quality guidelines (e.g., from Clean Code or Google Java Style Guide) recommend keeping methods under 20โ30 lines for maintainability, it is not a hard-and-fast rule.
๐ ๏ธ Tools & Standards
Various code quality tools like SonarQube and PMD allow configuration of method length thresholds. These tools often default to values between 20โ100 lines based on language or custom configurations.
โ Correct Answer: False
There is no universal standard that defines a method as “long” specifically at 20 lines of code. The appropriate method length is context-dependent and varies based on:
- Programming language used
- Codebase structure and modularity
- Teamโs internal coding standards
- The methodโs role and complexity
Therefore, declaring that a method is long simply because it exceeds 20 LoC is inaccurate in general software engineering practice.