Can the following be reasonably modeled with the basic energy model? Answer Yes or No for each: A box slides up and down a very smooth ramp. A baseball player slides into second base.

by
with no comment
Physics
Can the Following Be Modeled with the Basic Energy Model?

Physics Analysis: Applying the Basic Energy Model

Question:

Can the following be reasonably modeled with the basic energy model? Answer Yes or No for each:

  1. A box slides up and down a very smooth ramp.
  2. A baseball player slides into second base.
  3. A burner heats water to the boiling point.
  4. A burner heats a gas. The molecules move faster.

Answer:

Understanding the Basic Energy Model

The basic energy model includes only macroscopic kinetic energy and gravitational potential energy, and assumes the presence of only conservative forces (like gravity or springs). It neglects thermal effects, sound, and other forms of energy loss.

Situation-wise Evaluation:

(a) A box slides up and down a very smooth ramp

Since the ramp is described as “very smooth”, friction is negligible. The motion involves only conservative forces, and energy is transferred between kinetic and gravitational potential energy. This fits the basic energy model perfectly.

Answer: Yes

(b) A baseball player slides into second base

Here, friction is significant. Friction is a nonconservative force that converts kinetic energy into thermal energy and possibly sound. The basic energy model fails to capture this energy loss, making it unsuitable.

Answer: No

(c) A burner heats water to the boiling point

The energy here increases the internal energy of the water—raising temperature and eventually causing a phase change. These are microscopic energy changes not accounted for in the basic energy model, which focuses on bulk mechanical energy.

Answer: No

(d) A burner heats a gas. The molecules move faster

Again, the heat increases the internal kinetic energy of gas molecules. This increase in random microscopic motion is not included in the basic energy model, which only considers organized macroscopic motion.

Answer: No

Conclusion:

  • a. Yes
  • b. No
  • c. No
  • d. No

Only processes governed by conservative forces and involving large-scale mechanical energy transformations (like in part a) can be accurately modeled using the basic energy model.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *